Plan a Trip to the Finger Lakes With These Itinerary Tips & Ideas
Join me on Substack
Listen to this article
If you’re planning a trip to the Village of Skaneateles, New York, or the broader Finger Lakes region, I’m here to help. I’m breaking down my Skaneateles trip itinerary to give you inspiration for your own. Pair this with the detailed Skaneateles Destination Guide, and you’ll be set. And if you want to feel expertly prepared, listen to the immersive Globocurious episode about the region. You’ll feel like you’ve been there even before you go.
OK, let’s dive in!
Transportation & Accommodations
If you’re flying in, the closest airport to Skaneateles is Syracuse Hancock International Airport, about a 30-minute drive away. From there, I recommend renting a car. Public transportation in this region is limited, and having your own wheels is the best way to explore the surrounding villages, lakes, and historic sites at your leisure.
Skaneateles offers a range of charming lodging options. If you’re looking for something cozy and historic, try the Sherwood Inn. It’s located right on the lake and dates back to the early 19th century. The inn oozes charm and features an excellent on-site restaurant, which I’ll tell you more about in a bit.
For something more modern, Airbnb offers great options in and around the village. Many rentals are lakefront properties or have stunning views, giving you a taste of the lakeside lifestyle that makes Skaneateles so special. Just know, these rentals can get pricey due to the high demand and often large footprint of the lake houses, but they do come packed with amenities. Lake house rentals are an especially good option for groups of 5 or more.
Subscribe to the podcast so you don’t miss a beat.
Fun in the Finger Lakes
Now, let’s talk about what there is to do. The Finger Lakes region is home to unique attractions that highlight its rich history and natural beauty. Located just 30 minutes south of Skaneateles in Auburn, The Harriet Tubman House is a National Historic Park and an absolute must-visit. Harriet Tubman lived here for decades, and the site offers an intimate look into her extraordinary life and work. Be sure to catch Reverend Paul’s guided tour—he’s one of the most engaging storytellers I’ve encountered. Plus, your visit supports the preservation of this important piece of American history.
Auburn offers another great stop for history buffs: the Willard Memorial Chapel. It’s the only remaining chapel interior entirely designed by Louis Comfort Tiffany, and stepping inside feels like entering a kaleidoscope of color and craftsmanship.
For outdoor lovers, Green Lakes State Park is a gem about 45 minutes from Skaneateles. Its two glacial lakes are famous for their vibrant turquoise waters that look like they belong in the Caribbean – and I am not exaggerating. My family and I – spanning ages one to 76 – did the full loop around the lake, which clocks in at an easy and mostly flat two miles (with plenty of stop for photos along the way). It’s an ideal spot for hiking, picnicking, or simply marveling at nature’s beauty.
For a dive into the region’s industrial past, check out the Salt Museum on the shores of Onondaga Lake. This small but fascinating museum highlights the history of salt production, which played a major role in shaping this part of New York, something you’ll hear more about in the immersive episode.
The Skaneateles Historical Society Museum is another great way to learn about what has shaped Skaneateles over the years. It’s housed in the old Creamery building and showcases the area’s rich history through exhibits on everything from the lake’s role in local commerce to the region’s unique heritage.
And of course, Skaneateles is all about the lake and its surrounding natural beauty. If you’re there during the summer, you can rent a boat, kayak, or paddleboard from Skaneateles Marina to fully enjoy the water. If you do end up with access to a boat, don’t miss Sandy Beach, or “The Cove” as locals call it—a sandbar where locals anchor their boats, swim, and hang out with drinks in hand. Also during the summer, you can book several kinds of lake cruises with Mid-Lakes Navigation for a more structured but equally beautiful way to experience the lake.
Sink Your Teeth In
If you’re looking for casual, Doug’s Fish Fry is a Skaneateles classic. Their fish and chips are a local favorite, and the vibe is no-frills and welcoming.
For something with a view, Blue Water Grill offers a lakeside dining experience with a diverse menu. Their seafood and burgers are standouts, and the view of Skaneateles Lake adds that extra something special.
Then there’s Valentine’s Pizza. This is a true local staple. My sister-in-law’s parents opened it 30 years ago, and though they’ve recently sold it, it remains the go-to spot for delicious pizza, salads, wings, and sandwiches with a classic pizza shop atmosphere.
Finally, I have to mention the historic Sherwood Inn. This place is a destination in its own right, combining farm-to-table flavors with an ambiance that feels like stepping back in time. I ate a local staple there – Chicken Riggies, which they are able to make with gluten-free pasta for any of my fellow GFies out there.
“Relax, You’re in the Village”
The Village of Skaneateles itself is a joy to explore. Its main street is lined with charming shops and cafes, all locally owned. Pretty much everything you buy or eat here supports the regional economy, which makes wandering through the village feel even more meaningful.
If you’re visiting during the holiday season, you’re in for a treat. Skaneateles transforms into a Dickens Christmas village, complete with locals dressed as characters from A Christmas Carol. It’s pure magic.
Skaneateles offers the perfect mix of relaxation, history, and local charm. Whether you’re paddling on the lake, diving into its fascinating history, or indulging in its vibrant food scene, this Finger Lakes village will leave you enchanted.
Dive deeper into Skaneateles and the Finger Lakes with this immersive episode of Globocurious.
Leave a Reply